September 10, 2023: The Consolation of Water Lilies

Today we celebrate the Unitarian Universalist ritual called the Water Ceremony. Our congregation and the life we share together is like a river, always moving, always changing. We choose whether and how and when to enter into the flow, to share who we are in order to grow together.

Today we build a symbolic river with this water – water we have collected from our homes, from places around the world, even from Water ceremonies in years past. Together we will pour it from these separate vessels into this common container, and as we do we join once again the streams of our own lives into the river of our common life together.

To frame our ceremony today I’ve chosen 4 readings from the same text. It’s a book many of you know, because we read it together two or three years ago, led by our Green Sanctuary committee. It’s a memoir called Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Teachings of Plants. 

The author, Robin Wall Kimmerer is a mother, scientist, decorated professor, and enrolled member of the Citizen Potawatomi Nation. She lives in Syracuse, New York, where she is a SUNY Distinguished Teaching Professor of Environmental Biology, and the founder and director of the Center for Native Peoples and the Environment.

These four excerpts are all from Kimmerer’s Chapter Ten, called “The Consolation of Water Lilies.” I’ve added some illustrations on these slides, to help you enter the story.

Part 1. Loss
Before I knew it, and long before the pond was ready for swimming, they were gone. My daughter Linden chose to leave and put her feet in the ocean at a redwood college far from home. I went to visit her that first semester and we spent a lazy Sunday afternoon admiring the rocks of the agate beach at Patrick’s Point.

Walking the shore, I spotted a smooth green pebble threaded with carnelian, just like one I’d passed by a few steps earlier. I walked back, searching the strand until I found it again.

I reunited the two pebbles, letting them lie together, shining wet in the sun until the tide came back and pulled them apart, rolling their edges smoother and their bodies smaller. The whole beach was like that for me, a gallery of beautiful pebbles divided from each other and from the shore.

Linden’s way on the beach was different. She too was rearranging, but her method was to place gray with black basalt and pink beside a spruce green oval. Her eye was finding new pairings; mine was searching out the old.

I had known it would happen from the first time I held her— from that moment on, all her growing would be away from me.

It is the fundamental unfairness of parenthood that if we do our jobs well, the deepest bond we are given will walk out the door with a wave over the shoulder.

Oh We get good training along the way. We learn to say “Have a great time, sweetie” while we are longing to pull them back to safety. And against all the evolutionary imperatives of protecting our gene pool, we give them car keys . . . And freedom. It’s our job.

And I wanted to be a good mother. I was happy for her, of course, poised at the beginning of a new adventure, but I was sad for myself, enduring the agony of missing her. My friends who had already weathered this passage counseled me to remember the parts of having a house  full of children that I wouldn’t miss a bit. I would be glad to retire from the worried nights when the roads are snowy, waiting for the sound of tires in the driveway exactly one minute before curfew. The half-done chores and the mysteriously emptying refrigerator.

Reflection 1 

Susanne: As they say, the only constant in life is change. Everything all around us changes, all the time,

even the people and the places we know and love best. Especially the people and the places we know and love best. And Sometimes it hurts.

September is the season of change. New beginnings are always of course endings too.

Just a couple weeks ago, our eldest moved away. Far away, for the first time. Eli is 23 now, he graduated from Tufts in the spring, with a degree in computer science, and he’s off now to join the world of Silicon Valley. He’s a grownup of course, mature and responsible, but in my mind he’s still that blond toddler on a tricycle wearing his blue striped Thomas the Tank Engine conductor hat.

Our daughter Lily just moved back to the dorms at Tufts, for her second year there. And someone sent me apiece from the Onion that summed it all up perfectly. Here’s the headline – Mom’s Fears About Daughter Leaving For College Channeled Into Fight About Storage Bins.

Yup. 100%.

We want to say I love you and I’ll miss you. But somehow it ends up with stuff like “We’re only making this trip once, so if you want to just get a bunch of cheap garbage that’s going to fall apart, that’s up to you.” and “I can’t even deal with you right now.”

Parenting is hard. All kinds of relationships are hard. And we are always making mistakes, always. It’s okay to say that sometimes it hurts.

Is something changing in your life right now?

Is someone walking away?

Or Is there something else you need to let go?

I invite you to let any memories, any sadness you may have, any unease, come forward.

I invite you to hold it all gently, for just a moment, with the honor and the kindness it deserves.

Story Part 2: Letting Go

[I held in my heart all those memories, all those mornings when I’d get up] and the animals had beaten me to the kitchen. The calico cat yelled from her perch: Feed me! The longhaired cat stood by his bowl silently with an accusing stare. The dog threw herself against my legs with happiness and looked expectant. Feed me! And I did.

Then I dropped handfuls of oatmeal and cranberries into one pot and stirred hot chocolate in another. The girls came downstairs sleepy-eyed and needing that homework paper from last night. Feed me, they said. And I did.

I tipped the scraps into the compost bucket so when the next summer’s tomato seedlings say feed me, I can. And when I kiss the girls good-bye at the door, the horses whicker at the fence for their bucket of grain and the chickadees call from their empty seed tray: Feed me me me. Feed me me me.

The fern on the windowsill droops its fronds in silent request. When I put the key in the ignition of the car it starts to ping: fill me. Which I do. I listen to public radio all the way to school and thank goodness it’s not pledge week.

I remember my babies at the breast, the first feeding, the long deep suck that drew up from my innermost well, which was filled and filled again, by the look that passed between us, the reciprocity of mother and child.

I suppose I should welcome the freedom from all that feeding and worrying, but I’ll miss it. Maybe not the laundry, but the immediacy of those looks, the presence of our reciprocal love is hard to say good-bye to.

I understood that part of my sadness at Linden’s departure was because I did not know who I would be when I was no longer known as “Linden’s Mother.” But I had a bit of a reprieve from that crisis, as I am also justly famous for being “Larkin’s Mother.” But this, too, would pass.

Before my younger daughter, Larkin, left, she and I had a last campfire up at the pond and watched the stars come out. “Thank you,” she whispered, “for all of this.”

The next morning she had the car all packed with dorm furnishings and school supplies. The quilt that I made for her before she was born showed through one of the big plastic tubs of essentials. When everything she needed was stuffed in back, then she helped me load my supplies on the roof.

After we’d unloaded and decorated the dorm room and went out to lunch as if nothing was happening, I knew it was time for my exit. My work was done and hers was beginning. I saw other girls dismiss their parents with a waggle of fingers, but Larkin walked me out to the dorm parking lot where the herds of minivans were still disgorging their cargos.

Under the gaze of deliberately cheerful dads and strained-looking moms, we hugged again and shed some smiley tears that we both thought had already been used up. As I opened the car door, she started to walk away but then turned and called out loudly,

“Mom, if you break down in uncontrollable sobs on the highway, please pull over!”

The entire parking lot erupted in laughter and then we were all released.

Story Part 3

As it turns out, I did not need Kleenex or the breakdown lane. After all, I wasn’t going home. I had planned for this with my special grief-containment system strapped on top of my car.

When my children were growing up, I spent every weekend at track meets or hosting slumber parties, so I rarely found time to go out in nature alone. Now I was going to celebrate my freedom rather than mourn my loss. You hear about those shiny, red midlife crisis Corvettes? Well, my version of that – a shiny new red kayak – was strapped on top of the car.

I drove down the road to Labrador Pond and slipped my kayak into the water. Just remembering the sound of the first bow wave brings back the whole of the day. Late summer afternoon, golden sun and lapis sky between the hills that fold around the pond. Red-winged blackbirds cackling in the cattails. Not a breath of wind disturbed the glassy pond. Open water sparkled ahead, but first I had to traverse the marshy edges, beds of pickerelweed and water lilies so thick they covered the water.

The long petioles of the spatterdock lilies, stretching six feet from the mucky bottom to the surface, tangled around my paddle as if they wanted to keep me from moving forward. Pulling away the weeds that stuck to my hull, I could see inside their broken stalks. They were packed with spongy white cells filled with air, like a pith of Styrofoam, that botanists call aerenchyma.

These air cells are unique to floating water plants and give the leaves buoyancy, like a built-in life jacket. This characteristic makes them very hard to paddle through but they serve a larger purpose. Pond lily leaves get their light and air at the surface, but are attached at the bottom of the lake to a living rhizome as thick as your wrist and as long as your arm. The rhizome inhabits the anaerobic depths of the pond, but without oxygen it will perish. So the aerenchyma forms a convoluted chain of air-filled cells, a conduit between the surface and the depths so that oxygen can slowly diffuse to the buried rhizome.

All around me there were lilies in all stages of rising and sinking and reemerging, a waterscape of change that is hard to move through, but I bent to the task, pushing my red boat through the green.

I paddled hard and strong out to the deep water, pulling against the weight of the vegetation, eventually breaking free.

When I had exhausted my shoulders so they were as empty as my heart, I rested on the water, closed my eyes, and let the sadness come, adrift. Maybe a little breeze came up, maybe a hidden current, or the earth tilting on its axis to slosh the pond, but whatever the invisible hand, my little boat began to rock gently, like a cradle on the water. Held by the hills and rocked by the water, the hand of the breeze against my cheek, I gave myself over to the comfort that came, unbidden. I don’t know how long I floated, but my little red boat drifted the whole length of the lake.

Rustling whispers around my hull drew me from reverie and the first thing I saw upon opening my eyes were polished green leaves of water lilies smiling up at me again, rooted in darkness and floating in the light. I found myself surrounded by hearts on the water, luminous green hearts. The lilies seemed to pulse with light, green hearts beating with my own. There were young heart leaves below the water on their way up and old leaves on the surface, some with edges tattered by a summer of wind and waves and, no doubt, kayak paddles.

Scientists used to think that the movement of oxygen from the surface leaves of lilies to the rhizome was merely the slow process of diffusion, an inefficient drift of molecules from a region of high concentration in the air to low concentration under water.

But new inquiries revealed a flow we could have known by intuition if we had remembered the teachings of plants.

The new leaves take up oxygen into the tightly packed air spaces of their young, developing tissues, whose density creates a pressure gradient. The older leaves, with looser air spaces created by the tatters and tears that open the leaf, create a low-pressure region where oxygen can be released into the atmosphere. This gradient exerts a pull on the air taken in by the young leaf. Since they are connected by air-filled capillary networks, the oxygen moves by mass flow from the young leaves to the old, passing through and oxygenating the rhizome in the process.

The young and the old are linked in one long breath, an inhalation that calls for reciprocal exhalation, nourishing the common root from which they both arose. New leaf to old, old to new, mother to daughter—mutuality endures.

I am consoled by the lesson of lilies.

I paddled more easily back to the shore. Loading the kayak onto the car in the fading light, I leftover pond water drained out, onto my head.

I smiled at the illusion of my grief-containment system: there is no such thing.

We spill over into the world and the world

spills over into us.

The earth, that first among good mothers,

gives us the gift that we cannot provide ourselves.

I hadn’t realized that I had come to the lake

and said feed me,

but my empty heart was fed.

I had a good mother. She gives what we need without being asked.

I wonder if she gets tired, old Mother Earth. Or if she too is fed by the giving.

Story Part 4

It was dark when I got home, but my plan had included leaving the porch light on because a dark house would have been one assault too many. I carried my life jacket into the porch and got out my house keys before I noticed . . .

a pile of presents, all beautifully wrapped in brightly colored tissue paper, as if a piñata had burst over my door. A bottle of wine with a single glass on the doorsill.

My first thought was that there had been a going away party on the porch for Larkin and she had missed it. “That’s one lucky girl,” I thought, “showered with love.” I looked through the gifts for tags or a card, but there was nothing to show who had made the late delivery. The wrapping was just tissue paper so I hunted for a clue.

I smoothed the purple paper tight on one gift to read the label underneath. It was a jar of Vicks VapoRub! A little note fell from the twisted tissue paper: “Take comfort.” I recognized the handwriting immediately as my cousin’s, dear enough to be my sister, who lives hours away.

My fairy godmother left ME eighteen notes and presents, one for every year of mothering Larkin. A compass: “To find your new path.” A packet of smoked salmon: “Because they always come home.” Pens: “Celebrate having time to write.”

I realized  .  . . We are showered every day with gifts, but they are not meant for us to keep.

Their life is in their movement, their flow, the inhale and the exhale of our shared breath.

Our work and our joy is to pass along the gifts

and to learn to trust

that what we put out into the universe will always come back.